Sunday, 8 November 2015

What’s driving the young lone wolves who are stalking the streets of Israel?


What’s driving the young lone wolves who are stalking the streets of Israel?

Peter Beaumont’s Observer article October 18th on “What’s driving the young lone wolves who are stalking the streets of Israel?” leaves the central question unanswered.  The article represents a dangerous spin.  There is no room for naiveté or double standards when innocent people are slaughtered in the street.  The lacks of recognition for what these crimes are, hate-crimes, is irresponsible reporting.

Beaumont suggests that recent murders in the streets of Israel are ”indicative of more than simply the act of killing”.  He states that these murders are an “emblematic” form of violence, although he is not clear as to what these acts are emblematic.

When the terrorists who murdered British soldier Lee Rigby on a London street went on trial, the Court heard that the terrorists involved were inspired by an ISIS online fatwa and as a result of which they plotted to slaughter a British man.  Protesters outside the Old Bailey demanded capital punishment for all terrorists.  The Judge, Mr Justice Sweeney, branded these terrorists “traitors to their religion… a betrayal of Islam”, to which one defendant shouted at the judge, "you know nothing about Islam".[1]

In the case of Lee Rigby the British response was utterly dismissive of any terrorist grievances and ideology.  When Lee Rigby was knifed, everybody was horrified; but when Palestinians murder random passers by in Israel, Beaumont appears to regard it as a legitimate protest akin to the ‘Arab spring’.  He quotes the father of one of these killers as demonstrating a “pure intifada”.

Were the murderers of Lee Rigby any less ‘pure’?

Why is it when civilians are slaughtered in the streets of Israel, these murders are framed in a different way?  Can one political grievance justify the murder of innocent civilians while another does not?

What does a “knives intifada” have to do with the Arab spring?  This is the same Arab spring, which has reached Syria and led to a genocidal civil war.  Beaumont suppresses the fact that the current wave of stabbings of Jews in Israel imitates Islamic State terrorists, who have been using knives in graphically documented executions.

When Joseph's Tomb was set ablazed in Nablus last week, amid Palestinian calls for 'revolution'[2], the scenes were reminiscent of the Islamic State's destruction of non-Muslim holy sites in Syria and Iraq.  A prominent Palestinian journalist, Bassam Tawil has commented that these kinds of atrocities are not a struggle against occupation, the wall or the checkpoint, but an “Islamic State-inspired jihad to slaughter Jews and wipe Israel off the face of the earth.”  He further comments; “Our young men and women must have been watching too many videos of Islamic State jihadis shouting "Allahu Akbar!" as they beheaded or burned their victims.” [3]

Looking at the Facebook posts left by these youths, Beaumont reports that they want to die in a “heroic way”; does such ‘heroism’, which apparently entails stabbing a random Jews in the street including women children?

There is a complete inconsistency in Beaumont’s attitude to the violence in Israel, when compared with anywhere else in the world, where Islamist violence is seen as fanatics’ barbarity.  In the case of the Palestinians, he implies that there is something different to this violence without explaining why.   The real danger is when other Islamists see how Palestinian terrorism is received in the West this can inspire them to take a similar course.

An apologetic Western discourse towards Palestinian terrorism is a double standard.  This simple serves to encourage more Palestinians to resolve to terrorism.  If we are opposed to Islamist terrorism, whether that be ISIS or al Qaida, or lone wolf terrorists, we should be applying the same standard to Palestinians.  One cannot seek to explain hate crimes in relative terms as if, hate-crime in one part of the world can be acceptable because of one justification or another.  All hate-crime are unacceptable and must abhorred.


Eitan Arvats

No comments:

Post a Comment