Sunday, 8 November 2015

The Troubling Role of UNRWA

The Troubling Role of UNRWA
 May 2015

The civil war in Syria and the unfolding tragedy change the facts on ground at a pace faster than that to which Governments or humanitarian organizations are able to respond.  The Yarmouk neighbourhood in Damascus was home to some 160,000 residents, mostly the descendants of “Palestine refugees” from the 1948 Israel/Arab war.  According to UNRWA, the UN Work and Relief Agency, 90% of its population has depleted; the survivors dispersed, and their whereabouts not entirely known. 

The fate of 9 other Palestinian refugee camps in Syria is not much different.  As the civil war evolved, they came to be perceived as a threat by both the Syrian opposition and the regime.  Currently, it is estimated by UNRWA that 340,000 out of the 526,000 registered refugees are displaced, over a third of UNRWA facilities destroyed and access to areas where survivors are said to have fled, is limited by Assad’s forces.

Security conditions remain a pressing concern for the Agency as a whole; its ability to deliver services across Syria is restricted.  An UNRWA spokesperson revealed that 14 staff members have already been killed and 25 are missing.  He further warns that lack of services will leave a vacuum in the camps that might be filled by extremist groups.  However, groups such as ISIS and the Al-Qaeda-affiliate al-Nusra have already been present in the camps and most of the camps have been destroyed in the cross fighting.

Before the civil war broke out, “Palestine refugees” were absorbed into social and economic life in Syria.  According to UNRWA, most people who were registered were in fact not in humanitarian need; instead they utilized their right to send their children to free UNRWA schools. 

The civil war has devastated Syria as a whole; it is impossible to ignore that with UNRWA’s estimated 340,000 displaced persons on its books, there are a further 6.5 million refugees displaced within Syria. How UNRWA proposes to distinguish and assist “Palestine refugees” over and above other Syrian refugees is hard to say.  Again UNRWA finds itself in a difficult situation.

UNRWA’s circumstances have been problematic from its inception in 1949.  Although it was only commissioned to operate for one year, with 1/2 million registered refugees in 1950; there are now nearly 5.5 million registered refugees in 2015.  From an initial annual budget of $33 million, it has grown to $1.3 billion, in 2014.

UNRWA’s lifeline depends on predominantly Western government support, but in the words of its Commissioner-General Pierre Krähenbühl: "Palestine refugees need more than just aid.  They need a just solution." Therefore, for as long as that “just solution” is not found, the “Palestine refugee” problem persists.

As a consequence, UNRWA continues to register descendants of male “Palestine refugees” as ‘refugees’, whilst declining alternative resettlement solutions.  UNRWA insists on the Palestine refugees’ ideological “right to return” to traditional Palestine, namely the Israel of today.  This insistence is founded on a non-binding UN Res 194 passed in 1948.

Over the years, subsequent UN Resolutions advocated alternative solutions for “Palestine refugees”, notably resettlement in the host countries or 3rd party states.  However, successive Palestinian leadership and the Arab states have rejected these proposals.  Today, even a 4th generation newborn is not given nationality of the host Arab state into which they are born.

Although the UN has reaffirmed res. 194 on several occasions, it has never sanctioned the registration of descendants as “refugees”.  Nevertheless, UNRWA continues to register descendants, including those who are not in humanitarian need, and even those who are born within the Palestinian Territories, and even then at times of relative peace.  No one is ever taken off UNRWA’s list.

UNRWA’s 'refugee like' population is the only group in the history of the UN that declines resettlement in host countries or in 3rd party states.  Normally refugees seek solutions away from conflict but the “Palestine refugee” is the only group, which insists on a “right of return” to the state from which they claim to be terrorised.  This insistence is on the return to a state they do not even fully recognize and which is said to be the source of their grievances.

To date, UNRWA promotes the “right of return” in its schools, and in so doing it perpetuates a refugee identity and a sense of victimhood among children.  There is no “right of return” if it means creating a new injustice in the recipient country; it is an unrealistic solution that UNRWA indoctrinates.  Hateful indoctrination of young people is a destructive act; nonetheless, Western governments namely, USA, EU, UK, Sweden, Norway are the chief states who fund UNRWA and by default UNRWA’s indoctrination. 

UNRWA’s financial figures show that for the last two decades, 70% of its budgets were spent on education and only 6% on humanitarian “hardship cases”.   As UNRWA spends less on humanitarian aid and significantly more on education, it is questionable whether the donor states are aware of the outcome of their donations.

In a leaked 2010 “Palestine Paper” President Mahmoud Abbas admitted that the Palestinian “right of return” to Israel was “illogical”.  And yet, earlier in the Syrian war, President Abbas had a conditional offer from Israel to allow “Palestine refugees” from Syria into West Bank and Gaza.  Abbas replied that allowing such an arrangement would compromise the refugees claim of a right to return to Israel, and therefore “it's better they die in Syria than give up their right of return.”


Granting 5 million people the “right of return” into Israel is not only demographically problematic and a security risk, but also, on a practical level an impossible task for Israel to fulfil.  The claim for the “right of return” remains an insurmountable impediment for the Peace process. The Western states that fund UNRWA therefore need to revaluate the role that UNRWA plays in impeding the Peace process.

What’s driving the young lone wolves who are stalking the streets of Israel?


What’s driving the young lone wolves who are stalking the streets of Israel?

Peter Beaumont’s Observer article October 18th on “What’s driving the young lone wolves who are stalking the streets of Israel?” leaves the central question unanswered.  The article represents a dangerous spin.  There is no room for naiveté or double standards when innocent people are slaughtered in the street.  The lacks of recognition for what these crimes are, hate-crimes, is irresponsible reporting.

Beaumont suggests that recent murders in the streets of Israel are ”indicative of more than simply the act of killing”.  He states that these murders are an “emblematic” form of violence, although he is not clear as to what these acts are emblematic.

When the terrorists who murdered British soldier Lee Rigby on a London street went on trial, the Court heard that the terrorists involved were inspired by an ISIS online fatwa and as a result of which they plotted to slaughter a British man.  Protesters outside the Old Bailey demanded capital punishment for all terrorists.  The Judge, Mr Justice Sweeney, branded these terrorists “traitors to their religion… a betrayal of Islam”, to which one defendant shouted at the judge, "you know nothing about Islam".[1]

In the case of Lee Rigby the British response was utterly dismissive of any terrorist grievances and ideology.  When Lee Rigby was knifed, everybody was horrified; but when Palestinians murder random passers by in Israel, Beaumont appears to regard it as a legitimate protest akin to the ‘Arab spring’.  He quotes the father of one of these killers as demonstrating a “pure intifada”.

Were the murderers of Lee Rigby any less ‘pure’?

Why is it when civilians are slaughtered in the streets of Israel, these murders are framed in a different way?  Can one political grievance justify the murder of innocent civilians while another does not?

What does a “knives intifada” have to do with the Arab spring?  This is the same Arab spring, which has reached Syria and led to a genocidal civil war.  Beaumont suppresses the fact that the current wave of stabbings of Jews in Israel imitates Islamic State terrorists, who have been using knives in graphically documented executions.

When Joseph's Tomb was set ablazed in Nablus last week, amid Palestinian calls for 'revolution'[2], the scenes were reminiscent of the Islamic State's destruction of non-Muslim holy sites in Syria and Iraq.  A prominent Palestinian journalist, Bassam Tawil has commented that these kinds of atrocities are not a struggle against occupation, the wall or the checkpoint, but an “Islamic State-inspired jihad to slaughter Jews and wipe Israel off the face of the earth.”  He further comments; “Our young men and women must have been watching too many videos of Islamic State jihadis shouting "Allahu Akbar!" as they beheaded or burned their victims.” [3]

Looking at the Facebook posts left by these youths, Beaumont reports that they want to die in a “heroic way”; does such ‘heroism’, which apparently entails stabbing a random Jews in the street including women children?

There is a complete inconsistency in Beaumont’s attitude to the violence in Israel, when compared with anywhere else in the world, where Islamist violence is seen as fanatics’ barbarity.  In the case of the Palestinians, he implies that there is something different to this violence without explaining why.   The real danger is when other Islamists see how Palestinian terrorism is received in the West this can inspire them to take a similar course.

An apologetic Western discourse towards Palestinian terrorism is a double standard.  This simple serves to encourage more Palestinians to resolve to terrorism.  If we are opposed to Islamist terrorism, whether that be ISIS or al Qaida, or lone wolf terrorists, we should be applying the same standard to Palestinians.  One cannot seek to explain hate crimes in relative terms as if, hate-crime in one part of the world can be acceptable because of one justification or another.  All hate-crime are unacceptable and must abhorred.


Eitan Arvats

Terrorism and the West


Terrorism and the West – the Case of Israel and Palestine - Oct 2015

The recent wave of violence in Israel proves that the Israeli and the Arab/Palestinian conflict is a sectarian/religious conflict much like the other Middle Eastern conflicts, and not a territorial one relating to land or the “occupation”.

When reading the news about Palestine, Gaza or Israel, one gets the impression that there is a lot of violence going on.  Explaining the causes of this recent wave of violence, Western commentary invariably resorts to the familiar formula “Palestinians are frustrated with the peace process and see no end to the occupation”. This stale explanation of the “cycle of violence” at best holds both Israelis and Palestinians to account and yet at the same time, does not place the blame on anyone. 

Nevertheless, the violence is said to be mostly a result of the “occupation” and consequently, the frustration it brings.  In other words, the “occupation” is portrayed as an understandable justification for the violence, which suggests that before the 1967 occupation there was peace and harmony between the Arabs and the Jewish state, which was clearly not the case.

This persistent repetition of the same flawed formula for explaining the violence, leads to a position, where a higher Palestinian than an Israeli death toll apparently suggests a greater Israeli culpability.  No one is looking at the reasons lying behind the respective death tolls and the fact that the Palestinians repeatedly insist on “Intefada” and the use of violence as a way of dealing with differences.  However, why in Western commentary violence is acceptable as a natural response to frustration, no one dares to explain.

Why do so many Palestinians see the plunging of knives into the necks of Jewish civilians as a religious or patriotic duty or a moral fulfillment of sorts?  Is it just about “despair” at the peace process?  Are the Palestinians the only people who are politically frustrated?

In his recent UN speech, Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas announced that the Oslo Accords are null and void.  He later went on to say in an interview to the public that the “We bless every drop of blood spilled for Jerusalem, which is clean and pure blood, blood spilled for Allah… Al Aqsa Mosque is ours. They [the Jews] have no right to defile it with their filthy feet.”[1]

Traditionally Orthodox Jews considered the Temple Mount too holy for Jews to visit. Now, democratically elected Israeli representatives want to allow Jews to pray on the Temple Mount.  This would represent a change in the “status quo” and this has led Palestinian leaders to proclaim that the Al Aqsa mosque is in danger.  A danger, which according to Mahmoud Abbas is contamination by Jews’ "dirty feet", a particular slur as far as Muslims are concerned.

The Al-Aqsa mosque is positioned at the southern corner of the Temple Mount site also know in Arabic as Haram El Sharief.  Recently, Palestinian and Western commentators have started to refer to Haram El Sharief/Temple Mount as the  “Al Aqsa compound”. There is no such compound.  There is Haram El Sharief /Temple Mount, and there is the Al-Aqsa mosque within this compound, along with the Dome of the Rock and other archaeological treasures of religious importance.  There is room for everybody to visit and enjoy.  No one owns the site; it is a public space.  It is holy to all monotheist religions and it is not exclusively Islamic.  It is the Palestinians leaders who wish to forbid Jews from visiting the site, and it is Abbas while competing for popularity with Hamas, who has turned the issue into a religious war.

The incitements from Gaza spill into the West Bank.  On Oct 9, 2015 Mushir Al-Masri, a Hamas spokesperson in Gaza proclaimed in a public rally “...the knife is our choice. The knife symbolises the battle of the West bank and Jerusalem”[2].   On the same day, Rafah Cleric Muhammad Salah in Friday sermon, calls upon Palestinians to stab Jews, whilst waving a knife in the air: “My brother in the West Bank: Stab! My brother is the West Bank: “Stab the myths of the Talmud in their minds! My brother in the West Bank: Stab the myths about the temple in their hearts!”.[3]

The Palestinian blood fetish is no stranger to the Middle East; we have recently seen graphic scenes of executions with knives.  The fanaticism, the hate and the racism among Palestinian Islamists is no different to that of ISIS, where slaughter with knives is also the resolution to any difference or dissent.

It is time that the West stops endowing the Palestinians with the excuses that the Palestinians themselves barely bother to make.  There is a persistent failure in Western commentary, which stems from cultural relativism.  It is the 'noble savage' fallacy in which the indigenous people can do no wrong.  Whoever tries to defend this fallacy only gives rise to more violence and bloodshed.

Eitan Arvats



[2] #5099 - Hamas MP and Spokesman Mushir Al-Masri Brandishes Knife, Calls on All Factions to Join the "Jerusalem Intifada"; Al-Jazeera TV (Qatar) - October 9, 2015
[3] #5098 - Rafah Cleric Brandishes Knife in Friday Sermon, Calls upon Palestinians to Stab Jews - The Internet - October 9, 2015